Changeset 10492

Timestamp:

11/10/10 11:34:27 (3 years ago)

Author:

Snyder.Jason

Message:

changed end of introduction and moved some sections around

Files:

• ossiedev/branches/jsnyder/STTT_paper/sttt-draft.tex (modified) (24 diffs)

ossiedev/branches/jsnyder/STTT_paper/sttt-draft.tex

@@ -37 +37 @@
 %
 \begin{abstract}
-        A set of rapid development, control, and monitoring tools have been developed as part 
-        of the OSSIE open source Software Defined Radio (SDR) project, which is based on the 
-        U.S. Department of Defense Software Communications Architecture (SCA).  SDR is an 
-        emerging area of wireless communications in which radio functionality that was previously
-        implemented in analog hardware or digital application specific integrated circuits 
-        (ASICs) is instead implemented in programmable and reconfigurable processing devices.  
-        By moving this functionality into software, radios can be made more flexible to support 
-        a wide range of communications standards or waveforms, limited only by the capabilities 
-        of the software developers and the hardware on which the applications will run. 
-        Open source SDR software such as that supplied by the OSSIE project provides an important resource 
-        for education, research, and rapid prototyping in this interdisciplinary field that 
-        integrates several areas within Electrical Engineering, Computer Engineering, and 
-        Computer Science.  Rapid development tools are needed to abstract the complexities 
-        of the SCA from developers and speed application development.  The Waveform Workshop, 
-        a collection of tools for use with the OSSIE software, enables rapid development, 
-        observation, and debugging of OSSIE SDR waveform applications.  We describe the 
-        functionality and implementation of these tools as well as their use in an SDR 
-        application development work flow, and outline planned enhancements.\end{abstract}
+A set of rapid development, control, and monitoring tools have been developed as part of the OSSIE open source Software Defined Radio (SDR) project, which is based on the U.S. Department of Defense Software Communications Architecture (SCA).  SDR is an emerging area of wireless communications in which radio functionality that was previously implemented in analog hardware or digital application specific integrated circuits (ASICs) is instead implemented in programmable and reconfigurable processing devices.  
+By moving this functionality into software, radios can be made more flexible to support a wide range of communications standards or waveforms, limited only by the capabilities of the software developers and the hardware on which the applications will run. Open source SDR software such as that supplied by the OSSIE project provides an important resource for education, research, and rapid prototyping in this interdisciplinary field that integrates several areas within Electrical Engineering, Computer Engineering, and Computer Science.  Rapid development tools are needed to abstract the complexities of the SCA from developers and speed application development.  The Waveform Workshop, a collection of tools for use with the OSSIE software, enables rapid development, observation, and debugging of OSSIE SDR waveform applications.  We describe the functionality and implementation of these tools as well as their use in an SDR application development work flow, and outline planned enhancements.\end{abstract}
 %
 \section{Introduction}
@@ -61 +45 @@
 part of the OSSIE open source Software Defined Radio (SDR) project 
 \cite{Aguayo2009b}, \cite{ossieweb}, which is based on the U.S. Defense 
-Department's Software Communications Architecture (SCA) \cite{sca}, \cite{bard}, \cite{Aguayo2009a}.  These tools allow SDR students, 
-researchers, and developers to create signal processing components and 
-waveform applications for radio communications and to run, configure, control, 
-and monitor operation of these applications in real time.
+Department's Software Communications Architecture (SCA) \cite{sca}, \cite{bard}, \cite{Aguayo2009a}.  These tools solve several problems frequently experienced by developers working on SDR projects. First, they bring modern IDE technology to the SDR development life cycle. While developers have always been able to use a modern IDE when writing source code, there are no IDEs built with SDR development in mind specifically. The tools also automate much of the development process, making development easier and drastically reducing opportunities to make mistakes. Finally, the tools provide a means of monitoring and reconfiguring SDR applications in real time, making it much easier for developers to debug and refine their software.
 
 \subsection{Software Defined Radio}
@@ -81 +62 @@
 The OSSIE software, including the Waveform Workshop, is a widely used and distributed software package. There have been over 20,000 downloads of the OSSIE source code, ready-to-run live DVDs, and VMware images. We have confirmed that students and engineers at over 20 different universities, companies, nonprofit research centers, and government laboratories have used OSSIE. In addition, over US\$3 million in funding for OSSIE projects has supported over 20 graduate and undergraduate students, and more than 10 graduate theses at Virginia Tech, the Naval Postgraduate School, and elsewhere have used the software. OSSIE has served as the basis for three peer-reviewed journal articles, four online articles, and more than 20 conference papers, along with approximately 10 short courses and tutorials serving over 200 participants.
 
-\subsection{Direct Manipulation Tools}
-\label{introduction:directmanipulationtools}
-OSSIE existed before the Waveform Workshop, but was much more difficult to use.
-Component and waveform XML descriptors had to written and installed by hand.
-Controlling waveforms was limited to starting and stopping them, and there was
-no way to monitor or manipulate running waveforms. The Waveform Workshop
-addresses this by providing a direct manipulation interface when creating and
-running waveforms and components. For example, a user might want to create a
-waveform that consists of two components called A and B with a connection from
-A's output port to B's input port. Before the Waveform Workshop, the user would
-have to hand edit the XML descriptors for the waveform, adding elements for each
-component, as well as for the ports and the connection itself. With the Waveform
-Workshop, waveforms are created by simply dragging together icons
-that represent components. The component ports are automatically displayed, and
-connections can be made by dragging one port onto another. The Waveform Workshop then takes care of generating the correct XML descriptors. The Waveform Workshop also provides a direct manipulation interface for running and monitoring waveforms. The user can see a block diagram of a waveform showing each component, and can plot the output of any port. Finally, the user can view and update component property values in realtime, allowing him or her to observe the effects of changing properties.
-
 \subsection{Motivation for SCA-Based SDR Tools}
 \label{introduction:toolmotivation}
-
 The extensive nature of the SCA and its use of CORBA and XML both motivate and facilitate development of tools for SCA-based SDR development.  In most cases it is desirable to abstract the interface code required by CORBA from communciations engineers who develop signal processing compnents and waveform applications.  Fortunately, use of CORBA also allows SCA-based SDR software tools to interact with SCA core frameworks and applications that are running either locally or remotely, while tools can parse XML files to obtain information needed to perform a variety of functions.  Commercial tools for SCA-based SDR development are available \cite{SpectraCX}, but open source tools that work with OSSIE are needed for educational and research purposes.  The Waveform Workshop provides these capabilities to researchers, students, and other SDR developers who use the OSSIE SDR software.  Section \ref{waveformworkshoptools} introduces the tools, and Sections \ref{sdrapplicationdevelopment-oef} - \ref{sdrapplicationdevelopment-alf} describe their use in developing, configuring, and monitoring a waveform application.
 
-%-------------------- FIGURE: EMPTY WORKSPACE IN OEF --------------------
+%-------------------- FIGURE: SDR Development using Waveform Workshop --------------------
 \begin{figure*}
 \centering
@@ -114 +78 @@
 \section{The Waveform Workshop Tools}
 \label{waveformworkshoptools}
+SDR frameworks such as OSSIE can be used without a set of specially designed developer tools, but it is a difficult and error-prone process. Component and waveform XML descriptors have to written and installed by hand. Controlling waveforms is typically limited to starting and stopping them, and there is no easy way to monitor or manipulate running waveforms. The Waveform Workshop addresses this by providing a direct manipulation interface when creating and running waveforms and components. For example, a user might want to create a waveform that consists of two components called A and B with a connection from A's output port to B's input port. Prior to the introduction of the Waveform Workshop, the user would have to hand edit the XML descriptors for the waveform, adding elements for each component, as well as for the ports and the connection itself. With the Waveform Workshop, waveforms are created by simply dragging together icons that represent components. The component ports are automatically displayed, and connections can be made by dragging one port onto another. The Waveform Workshop then takes care of generating the correct XML descriptors. The Waveform Workshop also provides a direct manipulation interface for running and monitoring waveforms. The user can see a block diagram of a waveform showing each component, and can plot the output of any port. Finally, the user can view and update component property values in realtime, allowing him or her to observe the effects of changing properties.
 
 Currently, three tools make up the Waveform Workshop.  These tools can be used in an iterative process of creating, testing, and improving OSSIE signal processing components and waveform applications.  The tools are:
 \begin{enumerate}
-\item The OSSIE Eclipse Feature (OEF), a plug-in for the Eclipse open-source integrated development environment that provides capability for creation of both waveform applications and individual signal processing components.
+\item The OSSIE Eclipse Feature (OEF), a plug-in for the Eclipse open-source IDE that provides capability for creation of both waveform applications and individual signal processing components.
 
 \item The Waveform Dashboard (WaveDash), a tool that uses information and capabilities available through the SCA to provide an easily reconfigurable graphical interface for interacting with OSSIE waveform applications.
@@ -126 +91 @@
 \subsection{The OSSIE Eclipse Feature (OEF)}
 \label{toolsdescription:oef}
-
-OEF is a port of the OSSIE Waveform Developer (OWD), an open source python tool for rapid component and waveform prototyping.  OWD generated the necessary XML descriptors and CORBA-enabled skeleton implementations for SCA-based signal processing components and XML files that specify instantiation, interconnection, and deployment of these components to form waveform applications that implement end-to-end communications waveforms. In the case of signal processing components, the SDR developer who used OWD then had to fill in the implementation using his or her editor of choice. Finally, the component or waveform files had to be built and installed from the command line using automake tools. The motivation behind OEF was to duplicate the automatic generation functionality of OWD, while adding support for the rest of the development process. To do so, OEF was developed as a plug-in for the Eclipse IDE.
+OEF is a port of the OSSIE Waveform Developer (OWD), an open source python tool for rapid component and waveform prototyping.  OWD automatically generated the necessary XML descriptors and CORBA-enabled skeleton implementations for SCA-based signal processing components and XML files that specify instantiation, interconnection, and deployment of these components to form waveform applications that implement end-to-end communications waveforms. In the case of signal processing components, the SDR developer who used OWD then had to fill in the implementation using his or her editor of choice. Finally, the component or waveform files had to be built and installed from the command line using automake tools.  The motivation behind OEF was to duplicate the automatic generation functionality of OWD, while adding support for the rest of the development process. To do so, OEF was developed as a plug-in for the Eclipse IDE. Along with providing the automatic generation from OWD, OEF also takes care of building and installing components and waveforms, eliminating many opportunities for introducing user error. It also brings all the advantages of a modern IDE. This includes syntax highlighting of source code in multiple programming languages, a simple to use interface for version control systems such as CVS and SVN, and project management tools. 
 
 \subsection{The Waveform Dashboard (WaveDash)}
 \label{toolsdescription:wavedash}
-
 The Waveform Dashboard (WaveDash) is an interactive and configurable graphical user interface (GUI) tool that acts as a control panel for working with multiple SDR waveform applications and their components. This tool abstracts the SCA interfaces and the implementation of the OSSIE core framework. It provides a direct manipulation interface to control and configure SDR waveforms interactively. Users can install, start, stop and uninstall a waveform application, and also can configure the properties of its components in real time. Further, this tool allows the user to customize the interface on a per-waveform and per-component basis. Users can choose the type of widget they prefer to represent a particular property of a component and can also hide or unhide specific components or properties.
 
 \subsubsection{WaveDash Architecture}
 \label{toolsdescription:wavedasharchitecture}
-
-WaveDash was written using a Model-View-Controller (MVC) architecture. The model keeps track of the currently running waveforms along with waveforms on the system available to install. The controller maintains a connection with CORBA and the naming service and can query and configure components running on waveforms in real time. Finally, the view displays information from both the model and the controller. The WaveDash GUI front end was the first view written to work with the model and controller, but two others are currently under development. The first is a server to enable control of an OSSIE radio over http. The second is a command line interface to allow a user to control an OSSIE radio over an ssh session or via scripts. Both of these applications are simply alternative views that use the same model and controller as WaveDash. This allows them to easily connect to and manipulate an OSSIE Radio. 
+WaveDash was written using a Model-View-Controller (MVC) architecture. The model keeps track of the currently running waveforms along with waveforms on the system available to install. The controller maintains a connection with CORBA and the naming service and can query and configure components running on waveforms in real time. Finally, the view displays information from both the model and the controller. The WaveDash GUI front end was the first view written to work with the model and controller, but two others are currently under development. The first is a server to enable control of an OSSIE SDR application over http. The second is a command line interface to allow a user to control an OSSIE SDR application over an ssh session or via scripts. Both of these applications are simply alternative views that use the same model and controller as WaveDash. This allows them to easily connect to and manipulate an OSSIE SDR application. 
 
 \subsection{The ALF Waveform Application Visualization and Debugging Environment}
 \label{toolsdescription:alf}
-
 The initial ALF tool was contributed to the project by SAIC in 2007, and Virginia Tech has maintained and enhanced the tool since that time.  Implemented in Python, ALF interacts with a local or remote OSSIE Domain Manager via CORBA, and allows users to install, start, stop, and uninstall OSSIE waveforms, and to display the waveforms in block-diagram form.  ALF includes plug-in tools that can be used to inject signals into signal processing components and to monitor signals at various points in a waveform application, and users can develop their own plug-in tools using code from the supplied plug-ins as an example.  Additional features allow building ad-hoc applications from individual components at run time.
 
@@ -147 +108 @@
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-oef}
 
-
-
-
-
 \subsection{Creating a Component}
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-oef:creatingcomponent}
-
 OEF helps developers to create signal processing components.  The developer specifies characteristics of the component such as ports and reconfigurable properties, and generates CORBA-enabled skeletal code for OSSIE.  The developer then provides or links to signal processing code that implements the desired functionality.  While more complex components can be developed using the same approach, the following example describes creation of a simple signal processing component, an amplifier that scales the incoming signal by a constant gain factor.
 %-------------------- FIGURE: GENERATING NEW COMPONENT --------------------
@@ -186 +142 @@
 \subsection{Adding Ports to a Component}
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-oef:addingports}
-
 The next step is to add ports to the component. Ports allow components to communicate with one another. The user clicks on the Add button to bring up the Add Port dialog, as shown in Fig $\ref{fig:oef:addport}$. Next, the user enters ``amp\_output'' for the port name and selects. As defined by the SCA, a uses port is an output port while a provides port is an input port. Since this port will be an output port, the user selects uses from the type drop-down menu. To choose the type of interface, the user clicks the arrow next to Standard Interfaces and selects complexShort from the choices that appear. Finally, the user clicks ok and sees the new port in the Ports table. All three fields in the Ports table are editable in place, so the user can change the name, interface, or type of any port after it has been added. Selecting any port and clicking the Remove button will delete the port from the component. This component also requires an input port called amp\_input that is also a complexShort, so the user adds another port using the same process
 
@@ -201 +156 @@
 \subsection{Adding Properties to a Component}
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-oef:addingproperties}
-
 The final step to configure a component is to add any reconfigurable properties it will need. Our amplifier needs two properties: I\_gain and Q\_gain, which multiply in-phase and quadrature components of the signal, respectively. The user clicks the Add button in the Properties section of the CE to bring up the Add Property dialog as shown in Fig. $\ref{fig:oef:addproperty}$. The user enters ``I\_gain'' for the name and 1 for the value. The rest of the attributes are left as the defaults, so the user clicks Add Property. The process is repeated for a Q\_gain property.
         
@@ -218 +172 @@
 
         At this point, all of the configuration for the component is complete.  The next step is to generate the XML descriptors and skeleton implementation files. The user selects Generate Component from the OSSIE menu to start the generation. OEF will run the necessary make commands and show the output in the console view. After generation is complete, the new files will appear in the project explorer, as seen in Fig. $\ref{fig:oef:generatedproject}$.
-        
-        
+
 %-------------------- FIGURE: EDITING CODE IN OEF --------------------
 \begin{figure*}
@@ -230 +183 @@
 \end{figure*}
 
-
 \subsection{Filling in Implementation Code}
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-oef:implementation}
-
 Once the component has been generated, the user has to fill in the skeleton with implementation code. The user double-clicks on amplifierIQ.cpp in the Project Explorer to open the file in a C++ editor as shown in Fig $\ref{fig:oef:editingcode}$. After filling in the custom implementation that operates on the input signal using the specified property (gain) values, and sends the processed signal to the output port, he saves the file. As long as there are no errors, OEF automatically builds and installs the component to the filesystem.
 
@@ -285 +236 @@
 \subsection{Install a new waveform application}
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-wavedash:installingwaveformapplication}
-
 The WaveDash toolbar provides controls to start, stop or uninstall the waveform application denoted by the active tab.  The user has to click on the appropriate buttons on the toolbar to start, stop or uninstall a waveform application. 
 
@@ -300 +250 @@
 \subsection{Show/Hide Components}
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-wavedash:showhidecomponents}
-
-        The Component menu lists the components present in the waveform application denoted by the active tab. The user deselects the component RxDemo from the Component menu (Fig. $\ref{fig:wavedash:selectdeselectcomponents}$) to hide it as it does not have any properties to configure. This feature is particularly useful when the waveform comprises a large number of components and only few of them are required to be configured often.  
+The Component menu lists the components present in the waveform application denoted by the active tab. The user deselects the component RxDemo from the Component menu (Fig. $\ref{fig:wavedash:selectdeselectcomponents}$) to hide it as it does not have any properties to configure. This feature is particularly useful when the waveform comprises a large number of components and only few of them are required to be configured often.  
         
 \subsection{Configure Component Properties of a Waveform}
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-wavedash:configurecomponentproperties}
-
 The ability to configure component properties at runtime was urgently needed and was one of the prime motivations to develop WaveDash. Prior to development of WaveDash, OSSIE users had to either modify property values in OEF and rebuild the waveform or hand-edit the property values in the component or waveform XML files and restart the waveform to configure the component property values.  
 
@@ -322 +270 @@
 \end{figure}
 
-
-
 %-------------------- FIGURE: WAVEDASH - CHANGE PROPERTY CONTROL WIDGETS --------------------
 \begin{figure} 
@@ -336 +282 @@
 \subsection{Change Property Configuration Control Widgets}
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-wavedash:configurewidgets}
-
-       The component PRF files determine the data type for each property of the component. WaveDash does a default mapping of data type (mentioned in PRF files) to a GUI widget (control) and also provides an optional list of widgets which users can customize to their preferences. In this example, packet\_delay\_ms of TxDemo is mapped to a spin box by default. User right clicks on the spin box that brings a context menu with the list of optional widgets configurable for packet\_delay. The user selects slider (Fig $\ref{fig:wavedash:changepropertywidgets}$) and that changes the widget on the application GUI also. The configure option in the context menu is used to set minimum and maximum values for spin box and slider controls.
+The component PRF files determine the data type for each property of the component. WaveDash does a default mapping of data type (mentioned in PRF files) to a GUI widget (control) and also provides an optional list of widgets which users can customize to their preferences. In this example, packet\_delay\_ms of TxDemo is mapped to a spin box by default. User right clicks on the spin box that brings a context menu with the list of optional widgets configurable for packet\_delay. The user selects slider (Fig $\ref{fig:wavedash:changepropertywidgets}$) and that changes the widget on the application GUI also. The configure option in the context menu is used to set minimum and maximum values for spin box and slider controls.
        
 %-------------------- FIGURE: WAVEDASH - SELECT/DESELECT COMPONENT PROPERTIES --------------------
@@ -351 +296 @@
 \subsection{Show/Hide Component Properties}
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-wavedash:showhidecomponentproperties}
-
-       It is highly possible that a component may have so many properties that it is not convenient to display all of the properties at the same time. Users may wish to hide unwanted properties and keep only the frequently used properties on screen. In this example (Fig $\ref{fig:wavedash:selectdeselectproperties}$), the user right clicks on a component and deselects phase\_offset from the pop-up menu.
+It is highly possible that a component may have so many properties that it is not convenient to display all of the properties at the same time. Users may wish to hide unwanted properties and keep only the frequently used properties on screen. In this example (Fig $\ref{fig:wavedash:selectdeselectproperties}$), the user right clicks on a component and deselects phase\_offset from the pop-up menu.
       
 %-------------------- FIGURE: ALF - BLOCK DIAGRAM WITH PLUG-IN MENU --------------------
@@ -366 +310 @@
 \section{SDR Application Development Work Flow Part III:  Use of ALF Waveform Application Visualization and Debugging Environment}
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-alf}
-
 The ALF environment provides several capabilities that are helpful for troubleshooting and debugging waveform applications.  Like WaveDash, ALF allows users to install/uninstall and start/stop waveform applications.  ALF also lets users display running applications in block diagram form as shown in Fig. $\ref{fig:alf:block_diagram_plugin_menu}$, and inject and monitor signals at various component ports in the application using provided or user-developed plug-in tools by right clicking on the port (small rectangle on either side of the component) and selecting from a menu as shwon in Fig. $\ref{fig:alf:block_diagram_plugin_menu}$.  Additional features enable creation and installation of single-component waveform applications, and connections between ports on components in the same or different waveforms at run time.
 
 \subsection {ALF Plug-In Tools}
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-alf:plugins}
-
 Several plug-in tools for ALF are provided as part of the OSSIE distribution.  These tools are used to inject signals into component provides ports, and to display, record, or otherwise process the signals coming out of component uses ports.  The plugins are implemented in Python, and users can modify the plug-ins or develop their own based on those provided.
 
@@ -386 +328 @@
 \subsubsection{Speaker Tool}
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-alf:plugins:soundtool}
-
 The speaker tool, shown in Fig. $\ref{fig:alf:plugins:speaker}$, accepts signals in OSSIE's complexShort (2-channel, short integer) interface format and plays the signals through a computer's sound card.  It allows the user to set the sampling rate at which the signal will be converted to audio.
 
@@ -401 +342 @@
 \subsubsection{Plot Tool}
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-alf:plugins:plottool}
-
 The plot tool (Fig. $\ref{fig:alf:plugins:plot}$) also accepts signals from uses ports that employ the complexShort interface.  This tool displays the signal's spectrum on a normalized frequency scale or displays the quadrature vs. in-phase components of the signal in order to render the constellations of received digital signals.  In this mode, several symbols are shown that under ideal conditions would typically map to regularly spaced points, e.g. in a circle (phase-shift keying) or in a grid pattern (quadrature amplitude modulation).  In a realistic simulation or an operational radio, the symbols appear scattered about the nominal symbol points due to noise, fading, imperfect synchronization, or other anomolies.
-
 
 %-------------------- FIGURE: ALF - AWG TOOL --------------------
@@ -417 +356 @@
 \subsubsection{Arbitrary Waveform Generator (AWG) Tool}
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-alf:plugins:AWGtool}
-
 Using this tool, shown in Fig. $\ref{fig:alf:plugins:awg}$, users can select from among available signal functions, or read signals that are stored in data files.  This allows generation of signals off-line using software such as MATLAB or replaying signals that are captured over the air.
 
 \subsection{Launching Individual Components as Waveform Applications}
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-alf:compform}
-
 ALF includes a `compform' capability that packages individual components as self-contained waveform applications and deploys them to the default GPP device.  This is accessed by clicking on a component in the middle left panel of ALF (see Fig. $\ref{fig:alf:block_diagram_plugin_menu}$).  The compform feature allows a user to test individual components by using the plug-in tools to inject and monitor signals into and out of each component as the component runs in a stand-alone application.
 
@@ -437 +374 @@
 \subsection{Connect Tool}
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-alf:connecttool}
-
 The Connect Tool, shown in Fig. \ref{fig:alf:connect}, provides the capability
 to connect ports on components that are in the same or different waveform applications.  This capability, provided with the ability to create and run single-component applications, allows users to build ad-hoc applications by launching components as waveforms and connecting them at run time to form a temporary, larger composite application.  The composite application can be configured by configuring properties of its constituent applications using the WaveDash tool.  Further, the Connect Tool provides for automatic instantiation and tear-down of applications, and automated connections and routing of data among standard applications, single-component applications, and plug-in tools, by specifying the applications/components/plug-ins and behavior in an XML file.  This enables dynamic reconfiguration of SDR applications at run time, a capability that can be very useful in cognitive radio implementations \cite{Cormier2009}.
@@ -453 +389 @@
 \subsection{Relation of ALF with WaveDash}
 \label{sdrapplicationdevelopment-alf:relationwithwavedash}
-
 When used together, ALF and WaveDash allow the user to observe effects of parameter values on waveform operation interactively and in real time, as shown in Fig. $\ref{fig:alf:alfwavedash}$.  This is very useful for education, experimentation, and debugging of waveform applications.  ALF currently provides some of the same functionality as WaveDash, specifically the ability to install/uninstall and start/stop applications.  This functionality is included in both tools so that WaveDash can be used to run applications without the full ALF environment.  WaveDash can be launched from within ALF, and further integration is planned.  Planned changes include encapsulating all common functionality of the two tools in a python module or library.
 
@@ -462 +397 @@
 \section{Future Work}
 \label{futurework}
-
 The current state of the tools allows for the work flow shown in the preceding sections, and also allows applications such as SimpleWaveform to be prototyped as ad-hoc applications and then recreated in OEF.  Additional development of the tools will enhance this capability by providing the option to display multiple application block diagrams in the same window, make connections by dragging lines between component ports, and formalize ad-hoc applications by saving connection and deployment information in waveform XML files. 
 
@@ -483 +417 @@
 \section{Conclusion}
 \label{conclusion}
-
 This paper has described a set of open source SCA-based SDR development tools suitable for education, research, and rapid prototyping. These tools hide some of the complexity of the SCA while exploiting the features provided by the SCA to enable an interactive development process.  The development process includes creation of signal processing comoponents and waveform applications as well as execution, visualization, monitoring, testing, and run time reconfiguration of waveform applications.
 
 \section{Acknowledgements}
 \label{acknowledgements}
-
 This work was supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant No. 0520418, by Science Applications International Corporation, and by U.S. ARMY CERDEC.
+
 \begin{thebibliography}{00}
 
@@ -515 +448 @@
 
 \bibitem{Vanu}
-Vanu$^{\textregistered}$ Introduces the Anywave$^{\textregistered}$ MultiRAN - Wireless Industry's First Software Radio Shared Active Infrastructure Solution, \\Available:  http://www.vanu.com/media/Web%20Site%20Press%20Releases/vanu-multiran-final.pdf
+Vanu{\textregistered} Introduces the Anywave{\textregistered} MultiRAN - Wireless Industry's First Software Radio Shared Active Infrastructure Solution, \\Available:  http://www.vanu.com/media/Web%20Site%20Press%20Releases/vanu-multiran-final.pdf
 
 \bibitem{JTRS}